| 2022 | Trevor | Stevens | TMA/Mentone Grammar |
| 2021 | Bruce | Watkins | Old Mentonians Basketball Club |
| 2019 | Rick | Brown | Old Mentonians Basketball Club |
| 2019 | Ken | Speers | Old Mentonians Football Club |
| 2018 | Sharon | Ericksen | Old Mentonians Football Club |
| 2017 | Peter | Rogers | TMA Committee |
| 2015 | Neil | McCallum | Old Mentonians Football Club/TMA Committee |
|
| 2014 | Sam | Ingram | Old Mentonians Football Club |
| 2014 | Kris | Larson | Mentone Soccer Club |
| 2014 | Darryl | Stevens | Old Mentonians Cricket Club |
| 2012 | David | Stansfield | TMA Committee |
| 2011 | Cameron | Dunkerley | Mentone Soccer Club |
| 2010 | Tim | Macdonald | Mentone Soccer Club |
| 2005 | Tim | Holland | Mentone Hockey Club |
| 2005 | Josh | Burt | Mentone Hockey Club |
| 2003 | Keith | Gaston | Old Mentonians Cricket Club |
| 2002 | Svend | Samild | Old Mentonians Cricket Club/Old Mentonians Football Club/ Mentone Soccer Club/TMA Committee |
| 1999 | Stephen | Grey | Old Mentonians Football Club/ TMA Committee |
| 1999 | Vic | Stroumos | TMA Committee |
| 1996 | Ron | Bungey * | Old Mentonians Cricket Club/Old Mentonians Football Club |
| 1996 | Tony | Dayton * | Mentone Hockey Club |
| 1996 | Mike | Durack | Old Mentonians Football Club |
| 1996 | Ivan | Eaves | Old Mentonians Cricket Club |
| 1996 | Colin | Ericksen | Old Mentonians Football Club |
| 1996 | Bill | Granger | Old Mentonians Cricket Club |
| 1996 | John | Lolas | Old Mentonians Cricket Club |
| 1996 | Alan | Munt | Mentone Hockey Club |
| 1996 | Garry | Norton | Old Mentonians Football Club |
| 1996 | Mark | Pearman | Old Mentonians Basketball Club/TMA Committee |
| 1992 | Bruce | Lobb | TMA Committee |
